Review

The Artist

  • Review Date: November 23, 2011
  • PG-13
  • Genre: Drama
  • 2011

Common Sense Media says

Loving tribute to silent films has a few tense moments.
Age
13
Quality
 

  • The movie celebrates friendship/loyalty, old Hollywood, and the magic of the movies, though it also suggests that "progress" is inevitable -- and that some people, especially those who are no longer young or fresh, may be cast aside in the process. Characters eventually learn difficult lessons about being overly proud and turning away help and affection when they're offered.
  • George starts out full of confidence and cheer (albeit with a tendency to hog the limelight); as his fortunes change, so does his outlook. Frustration and self-pity eventually overwhelm him, but he fights his way out of their shadow and learns that it's not beneath him to accept help and friendship from others. Peppy overall lives up to her name -- she's determined and goal-oriented, but she's also cheerful, loyal, and energetic.
  • In one tense/upsetting scene, it appears as though a character is going to commit suicide with a gun (he puts it into his mouth). Also, the movie opens on a mild torture scene (a character is shocked via electricity) that turns out to be part of a film within the film -- as are a few quick fight/chase scenes that follow. Another film-within-a-film sequence shows someone falling victim to quicksand. Also, a car crashes, and a reckless fire gets out of control and causes damage to property and one character.
  • Some flirting, longing glances, close dancing, and chaste embraces.
  • One use of "damn" (on title card); one rude gesture (a character flips someone off).
  • Not applicable.
  • Very frequent smoking (accurate for the era); mostly cigarettes, but also some cigars. Adult characters also drink (mostly cocktails/hard liquor), sometimes to excess; while drunk, one character has visions and makes a rash, dangerous decision.

What parents need to know

Parents need to know that The Artist -- a black-and-white homage to Hollywood's silent movies of the 1920s -- is nearly silent itself, relying on characters' gestures and expressions, the musical score, and occasional title cards to tell its story of fame, fortune, and friendship. As such, it might not appeal to many kids, but those who really love movies may be drawn in by its references, setting, and old-fashioned celebration of cinema. There are a few tense/violent scenes, including one in which a distraught character puts a gun in his own mouth and another in which a fire gets out of control. You can also expect lots of era-accurate smoking and a fair bit of drinking, including some overindulgence. But there's virtually no language or sexual content, and in the end characters learn important lessons about the value of friendship and humility.


This review of The Artist was written by
Age
13
Based on 11 parent & educator reviews:
  • 82% say there are positive messages
  • 73% say there's too much drinking, drugs, or smoking
  • 64% say violence is an issue
  • 64% say there are positive role models

Most useful reviews by all members

Adult
November 23, 2011
 
Surprisingly entertaining - a delightful film!
Who would ever think watching a silent film would fill you with more joy and entertainment than anything else playing in theaters? Well, I was surprised to realize that "The Artist" is really the most refreshing and delightful film of 2011 that I have seen. Because it is a silent film -- exquisitely done -- your left brain takes a much-needed rest and you are on a freedom ride with your right brain. The film is a breath of fresh air in this regard. The story is lovely. The actors are sensational. The choreography is perfection. You'll laugh, maybe cry. You will be entertained. I love this film!

Kid, 11 years old
December 26, 2011
 
Great!
Awesome! It's really something. This movie is very original! Nobody has ever made a silent movie since Mel Brook's "Silent Movie". It also has a great acting job done by Jean Dujardin and Berenice Bejo.

Adult
January 2, 2012
 
Amazing tribute to Hollywood's golden age is, hands down, the best film of 2011! Perfectly appropriate for older kids who love film.
In this age of CGI, 3D and Technicolor landscapes galore, it's quite strange to see a black-and-white movie in a 1:33 aspect ratio (instead of 16:9 widescreen, the norm these days) that's silent with intertitles about 95% of the time. What's even more surprising is that many are calling it the best film of the year. I couldn't agree more. The Artist is simply delightful, and film fans of (almost) all ages should check this one out. The story has elements from classic films like A Star is Born, Singin' in the Rain and Citizen Kane, yet feels quite original. Between the years 1927 and 1932, a famous film actor named George Valentin gets left out in his studio's transition to "talkies," while Peppy Miller, a young starlet he made famous, gets tons of exposure by starring in them. "Out with the old, and in with the new," the studio's lead executive says, and George gets progressively more distraught, but Peppy ends up saving him from his despair. I won't tell you anything else, because all film lovers and people who are tired of derivative blockbusters need to see this film. Also, despite the PG-13 rating, it actually has very little objectionable content to speak of, and is right on the fence between PG and PG-13. The sparse list of MPAA content descriptors confirms this: a disturbing image (a brief but somewhat intense suicide attempt, but it's interrupted and not very graphic) and a rude gesture (a woman giving a man “the finger”). There's also plenty of smoking and drinking, and while the former is definitely glamourized at times (smoking scenes in black-and-white do look beautiful, after all), it's firmly placed in the 1920s time period that it's set in. The drinking is condemned, as a decision made by an inebriated character ends up putting his life in danger. Overall, though, if you love film and don't mind the fact that it's a silent movie produced in a technologically advanced age, The Artist will delight you. Plus, not only do the human actors put on amazing performances, but the film's canine star, Uggy, is also quite a riot.

Teen, 15 years old
January 16, 2012
 
The ultimate for movie buffs!
While this film will likely be crowned the Best Picture of 2011, I don't think it's the year's best offering. On the plus side, "The Artist" is a 100% unique masterpiece that looks as if it couldv'e been made in the 1930's! Dujardin and Bejo's performances are equally inspiring, while familiar faces John Goodman & James Cromwell turn in fine supporting roles. Expect to see "The Artist" with many Oscars come late February!

Teen, 14 years old
February 4, 2012
 
Such a good movie! the PG-13 is kind of tame.
My rating: PG [borderline with PG-13] for some violent images, smoking and a brief crude reference. Violence: 2.5/5 - A non-graphic electrocution scene; a man attempts suicide in a fire and with a gun. Drugs: 3/5 - Smoking.

Kid, 11 years old
February 3, 2012
 
Black and White Film Entertains
This black and white film entertains. It should not have been rated PG-13, it should have been rated a high PG. There is a lot of smoking, but that shouldn't be a problem for kids. There are some mildly intense scenes including an attempted suicide, but that also shouldn't be a problem. There was a woman pointing the finger in the beginning of the film, but kids will most likely not notice that. It has mild positive messages and role models. This will attract the Academy and I am almost certain that this will win Best Picture. In my opinion, this is not my favorite film of 2011 (Hugo and War Horse are), but it's definitely in my Top 5. Don't underestimate black and white!

Teen, 13 years old
January 29, 2012
 
!!!!!
This is such a great, wondrous movie! And they pulled it off with no sound or color! Come on, this deserves 5 stars! A 6-yr-old I know looooooooooooooved it. And she usually can't sit through a movie with sound or color. Everyone should see it in my opinion.

Teen, 13 years old
January 21, 2012
 
Great family movie for those who will enjoy it.
This is a fabulous film, I absolutely loved it! It's a great homage to silent films that was perfectly done1 The acting was fabulous and the overall message was happy, but it did have its more tense and sad parts. I must say, there are only a select few teens that will actually enjoy this film, so make sure your teen is mature and will truly appreciate this film before taking them!

Kid, 11 years old
February 7, 2012
 
The Artist, painted my life with understanding and fascination!!!
The Artist is a must see!!! So creative and keeps you at the edge of your seat!! In my opinion, its safe just make sure your kids under stand those days with the drinking, also with going deaf (crazy), suicidal thoughts (in the begging its hard but its a movie in a movie). It may seem rough from what I typed but its not bad. Completey enjoy the night get out and watch this movie that one a few golden globes!!!

Kid, 10 years old
February 16, 2012
 
WATCH!!!!!!!!!!! WATCH!!!!!!! WATCH!!!!!!!!!!
THIS IS THE BEST MOVIE OF ALL TIME

(NR, 1952)

Often considered the finest musical of all time.

(R, 1994)

Depp-led cult-director bio delves into cross-dressing, kink.

(PG-13, 1999)
Entertaining, great actors but not a home run.