Review

Slumdog Millionaire

  • Review Date: November 11, 2008
  • R
  • Genre: Drama
  • 2008

Common Sense Media says

Epic romance-drama is brilliant but too mature for kids.
Age
15
Quality
 

  •  Modern-day India is depicted as a complex, rich culture of wonderful opportunity and yet terrifying poverty. Police forces are depicted as brutal, but they ultimately do the right thing. Criminal, greedy, and venal behavior is depicted -- and not always punished.
  • Through brains, principles, and decency, the lead character achieves in the face of poverty, prejudice, and evil.
  • Strong violence; the lead character is beaten, drowned, and electrically shocked by authorities in order to elicit a confession; a depiction of a religious riot includes beatings, on-screen deaths, and men being set ablaze. A young child shoots a man in a clear kill-or-be-killed situation. A young boy is blinded with hot oil to increase his value as a beggar. A woman's face is deliberately scarred with a knife. Fist fighting and other shooting deaths.
  • A supporting character is being taught courtesan's skills before being sold into sex slavery (at a high price due to her status as a virgin); some kissing; implied semi-sexual activity between a pre-teen boy and girl. Non-sexual nudity (a child's buttocks are seen).
  • Strong, including "s--t," "hell," "damn," "crap," "piss," "bugger," "p---y," and non-sexual uses of "f---ing."
  • The plot revolves around the Indian version of Who Wants to Be a Millionaire?
  • Constant smoking; characters (in some cases even very young children) drink hard liquor.

What parents need to know

Parents need to know that despite incidents of violence and cruelty, this is a sweeping, thrilling drama that mature teens will be able to take -- and will probably very much enjoy. There's some extreme violence -- electrocution, murder, and violence perpetrated by, and on, young children -- but it never feels exploitatitive or simplistic. The film revolve around issues of class (how could a poor "slumdog" like the lead character possibly do so well on Who Wants to Be a Millionaire?). and includes many images of modern India, including real -- but still hard-to-take -- depictions of poverty and hopelessness.


This review of Slumdog Millionaire was written by
Age
14
Based on 36 parent & educator reviews:
  • 42% say violence is an issue
  • 28% say language is an issue

Most useful reviews by all members

Teen, 15 years old
April 19, 2011
 
Amazing film is inspiring, but too mature for younger children.
Slumdog Millionaire is a powerful story about true love, and its struggles. The film is absolutely beautiful, and entertaining. And if you haven't seen it be sure not to miss it. Parents Section: Violence: The violence in the film is not graphic, and is kept at a PG-13 level, although some of the violence involves children which makes it slightly more disturbing. The film starts with the main character being beaten, nearly drowned to death, and electrocuted by police officers. The violence is much milder then it sounds. A scene takes place where a riot against, Muslims is being held. This scene includes; burnings, beatings, and murder. The scene lasts for about 2 minutes, and is quickly edited making it "again" much milder then it sounds. There is also a scene where a man blinds a boy with hot oil, using a spoon to drop it into his eyes. As he pours the hot oil into his eyes, it is blurred. Making it once again, milder then it sounds. Language: There are some cuss words in the film, but not what you would expect from an R rated movie. The words used are "S--t", "Hell", "D-mn", "Cr-p", "P---y", and two non-sexual uses of "F--ing" The words are only said through some parts of the film, and is not used at a constant rate. Sex: A main character, in a female role is sold into sex slavery, though it is only implied. As well other sexual scenes are only implied and not shown. A very young boy's buttocks are seen in a non sexual way. The strongest scene in the film when pertaining about sex would be when two young boys enter a brothel. And see a quick glimpse of a man and a woman kissing, although they are both clothed at this point and no nudity is visible. Drinking/Drugs: Many drinking, and even up to the point where some children are seen drinking hard liquor. Messages and Role Models: There are consequences to the bad things that characters do in the film. As well as messages about doing whatever it may take to make your dreams come true.

Parent of 10 and 15 year old
March 2, 2009
 
R Rating is Appropriate!
This movie is very violent and disturbing. I found the Commonsense review to be misleading in terms of the level of violence so I was shocked when I viewed the movie. In the opening scene Jamal is brutally tortured by the police, not simply dragged in for questioning. Children are abused and exploited. Do the parent/Kid reviewers really think this should be rated PG-13? Several "Harry Potter" movies are rated PG-13 as is "Apollo-13," among others! Neither contains graphic violence the likes of "Slumdog." PG-13 movies often are seen by younger viewers and I think the R-rating serves well as a red flag for parents. Nobody under age 18 should be exposed to this kind of violence. In addition the ending is very Western--Jamal and Latika, coming from the slums without parenting, somehow manage to look like fashion models with perfect features, teeth and manners. The message of the film, while moving at times, is not quite believable.

Parent of 7 year old
February 26, 2009
 
Way too much violence
I have to disagree with the "acceptable" level of violence discussed in some of the reviews. I felt it was very violent and edited in such a way that exacerbated it, creating an extreme level of tension that was difficult to bear. I admit I have a low level of tolerance for violence in any movie, but during the first half of the film I had to cover both my eyes and my ears regularly, not to have to witness what was going on. I have to question what it is about our culture that tolerates this level of violence in our movies (and some critics don't even mention it!)and have it be okay to have our teenagers watch it?

Adult
April 20, 2009
 
Horrible and Highly Overrated..
This film was horrible! This has got to be the most overrated film of all time. Does not diserve its Oscar wins. Talk about injustice.

Parent of 13 year old
April 20, 2009
 
Children are abused, adults tortured on-screen
I think this movie is popular because of the novelty of filming in India. If it were about a poor child from the slums of Detroit who prevails, I wonder if it would have been as popular. As the reviewer above said, that Jamal and Latika could have suffered as much and end up looking like models could happen only in the movies. This movie isn't for kids. It's every child's nightmare. The Mother is killed in front of them, adults kick them and don't care about them, other children are bullies. I'd heard about the eye-gouging scene so I covered my eyes. Yikes!

Adult
July 27, 2009
 
Good Movie
It was a great romance story but benjamin button was better.

Teen, 13 years old
August 28, 2009
 
PERFECT.
I LOVE THE MOVIE. THIS WAS AMAZING. IT'S EDUCATIONAL AND ENTERTAINING.

Kid, 12 years old
January 16, 2010
 
A very sad film full of violence and child abuse, though five stars with no arguments about it. Pretty disturbing, too.

Teen, 13 years old
February 2, 2011
 
Overated
Its a good movie just not astonishing. I think this movie is a bit overrated in my opinion. There's some violent material but not much. Its worth a view or two.

Teen, 14 years old
October 18, 2010
 
Amazing movie, one of the best.
This is an absolutely amazing movie. By far one of the best movies that I have ever viewed. It really shows the true side of India, and what is truly happening, and what people do go through. This movie was brilliantly, acted, and directed. This movie definitely deserved all the awards that it got, I have never seen (and probably never will) a movie quite like this one. There is some violence, but I have seen PG-13 movies with worse. I think the only reason it was rated R was because of language (which wasn't that bad). I would highly recommend this movie. Absolutely amazing.

(PG, 2005)
A rare family film that's not just for kids.
(PG-13, 1994)
Outstanding drama about morals and our choices.
(R, 2000)

Terrific story of young ballet dancer has strong language.