Review

Lassie

Common Sense Media says

Schmaltzy return for classic cinema canine.
Age
8
Quality
 

  • Lassie faces adversity bravely and helps many people during her adventures. On the other hand, dogs are beaten (and, in one scene, so is a person, who is simultaneously mocked), Joe's parents go back on their promise to him, and Joe is forced to turn against his beloved dog.
  • Lassie gets whipped (off-screen). Another dog dies at the hands of a person. The puppeteer is beaten up. Slapstick farce. Joe gets his hand whacked with a ruler at school.
  • Mild innuendo between characters.

What parents need to know

Parents need to know that this movie is a tear-jerker and contains some intense scenes involving poverty and peril. In one scene, Joe is forced to tell Lassie that he doesn't love or want her anymore (a potential weepy moment for the youngest set). Also, Lassie gets whipped, and in another scene, a brave little dog dies at a human's hands. There's also slapstick farce at the expense of some dog wardens. In school, Joe suffers humiliation and physical abuse from a teacher. A dwarf puppeteer is beat up by two big guys using clubs. They make snide remarks about his size and try to rob him.


This review of Lassie was written by
Age
10
Based on 3 parent & educator reviews:
  • 33% say violence is an issue

Most useful reviews by all members

Parent of 3 and 7 year old
March 15, 2010
 
not for primary school age children or younger
Overall it has many good points, consistent with reviews you will find elsewhere but the violence makes it unsuitable for younger children and anybody who likes animals will not enjoy seeing a dog beaten to death. I wish that I had not shown it to my children (7 and 3), although fortunately the little one had wandered off by this point. Seeing Lassie getting a belting was also pretty awful. Not at all what I had hoped for, based on half remembered episodes of Lassie from my childhood. The supposed drug abuse and bad language highlighted as potential issues on this site, will probably not even register as you reel from the violence!

Kid, 12 years old
April 9, 2008
 
i cried....
this movie was the best movie ive seen all year it was so cool though that Lassie traveled so far did so much just to see the boy again but its also very sad.... because when lassie dose get back she is almost dead................

Adult
April 9, 2008
 
Animal Peril is Poignant
The main review correctly says Lassie is lashed and another dog is beaten to death. The blows landing are not shown but every thing else is. These are very emotional scenes. Our 11 year old, who loves animals, just made it through OK. A younger sensitive child might not. If your child is mature enough the movie is worth it. Be aware that is a slow moving film with deep messages; it will not hold the attention of a young or hyper child.

Adult
April 9, 2008
 
Be warned!
I am usually quite careful about which movies my daughter (currently 7) gets to see, and I usually use this site as my primary source of guidance. We saw this dvd title at Blockbuster and rented it without doing the research because my daughter enjoyed the other G rated "Lassie" film. BIG MISTAKE! My daughter loves animals, especially dogs, but I would not say she is overly sensitive. She has seen other movies with some danger and peril to animals, and came through fine, without any tears or looking away. (In fact, there have been movies where her friends have walked out, claiming to be too scared, where she was perfectly fine.) THIS film was a different story, however. Parents need to know that one adorable little dog, a playful, sweet, friend to Lassie, is beaten to death with a club by some thugs who steal money from and attack its owner (a kind but helpless dwarf). It is a horrendous scene, and seemingly so unnecessary to the storytelling. It does not even move the plot forward and seems quite gratuitous. And then Lassie has to travel a tremendous distance, from Scotland to England, and when she arrives back home, she is near death. This was all very intense and nightmare-inducing for my daughter and I regret that she saw it. It is a decent movie over all -- good, but not great. The cinematography is probably the best part. But please be warned. You may want to wait until your child is older or skip it altogether. There are much better family films out there with animals (such as Homeward Bound, or Garfield, just to name a couple).

Teen, 15 years old
February 12, 2012
 
Awesome
Amazing remake. Really epic.

Kid, 12 years old
January 10, 2013
 
A Really Good Adaption
I read the book for my homeschool curiculum. I always see the movie that's based on the book I read. There's a scene where Lassie gets beat up, but nothing else is an issue. My 8 year old sister was 7 when she saw this. She's sensitive to animals, but this didn't bother her very much. Why do so many parents say a movie's bad just because the think it's innapropreat, or because their kids were scared? That's not right! I think Homeward bound is just as good as this, but I doubt that Garfield is better. It didn't get very many good reviews from critics.

(G, 1993)
Adventurous animal tale will have kids riveted.
(G, 1974)

Adorable dog saves the day in '70s classic.

(by Kate DiCamillo)

This poignant novel is one of the best around.