Review

Brave

Common Sense Media says

Mother-daughter princess tale has some very scary scenes.
Age
8
Quality
 

  • Kids will pick up some stuff about Scotland: the culture, the clans, the ancient dress, the idea that noble girls were often forced to marry out of obligation and alliance rather than love. They will also learn a bit about Scottish lore regarding the druid witch and will o' the wisps.
  • The movie focuses on how an at-odds mother and daughter can mend their relationship and learn from each other. A mother is fierce when it comes to defending her daughter, and vice versa. The way that Merida and Elinor work together is a beautiful tribute to the bond between mother and child. The movie also teaches the idea that "legends are lessons" -- stories that can teach us all about follies like pride, greed, and selfishness.
  • Merida is strong-willed, stubborn, and smart: She wants to find her own way in the world, not be tied to a suitor for betrothal before she's ready for marriage. While she's independent and brave, she does make a misguided decision about how to deal with her disagreement with her mother. Elinor has many of the same qualities she has trouble dealing with in her daughter. She's a kind, intelligent queen with a strong sense of duty and how she must comport herself. During their shared ordeal, both mother and daughter learn to think more like the other, and, as a result, they each change for the better. Many of the supporting characters -- especially the clan chiefs and their warriors -- are broadly caricatured for the sake of humor; they brawl constantly, make rude noises, etc.
  • There are several intense/scary scenes in Brave revolving around a giant, frightening bear; some of them may be too much for younger or more sensitive kids. The bear attacks King Fergus in the opening sequence (viewers learn that it tore off his leg; he has a wooden stump), and later it rages against Merida, Elinor, and the entire congregation of Scottish clansmen. Possible spoiler alert: Elinor's transformation into a bear is mostly funny, but in one scene that could upset younger kids, she becomes more bear than mother and growls menacingly at Merida. Young kids might also be frightened when the men (including Fergus) take arms against bear-Elinor and are set on killing her. The climactic battle between the bears and the clan gets very tense, especially when it looks like Merida or Elinor will be hurt. Some of the scenes with the witch may also be scary for kids -- she's mostly harmless, but her hut is spooky, and she comes off as creepy herself. The will o' the wisps are eerie and a bit ominous. The Scotsmen fight constantly, using both their bodies (hands, fists, teeth, feet) and weapons (swords, arrows, etc.) on their opponents.
  • Fergus and Elinor are an affectionate married couple; he smacks her on the bum, and, later, when she's naked under a sheet (nothing is seen below her neck), he stares at her until she reminds him that others are around, too. The men are naked under their kilts, and in a couple of scenes, animated naked rear ends (both of adult men and young boys) are briefly glimpsed. A housemaid has ample cleavage.
  • Not applicable.
  • Although there are no product placements in the actual film, Brave already has much merchandise available: dolls, costumes, apps, storybooks, a soundtrack, video games, apparel, and more.
  • The Scotsmen gather in the castle for a feast before it devolves into a brawl, and there are steins of drink, presumably some sort of mead or ale, but it's not referenced, and no one is represented as drunk.

What parents need to know

Parents need to know that Brave is pretty scary for a "princess movie," especially for kids under 7 and/or those who are very sensitive to peril. Several intense sequences involve a large angry bear that attacks the main characters -- which are even more so when seen in 3-D -- and (possible spoiler alert) a possibly disturbing but mostly comical transformation of a mother into a bear. A moment when the mom-turned-bear temporarily forgets she's human and growls at her daughter could upset younger kids. There's also a lot of brawling among the Scotsmen, who use both weapons (arrows, swords, etc.) and their bodies (fists, teeth) on each other. The first Pixar movie to revolve around a female main character, Brave does have a strong message about family relationships and open communication between parents and kids (particularly mothers and daughters). There's no romance for Princess Merida, but you can expect a few jokes about men being naked under their kilts; a couple of scenes even include quick glimpses of naked cartoon bums belonging to men and three young boys. Although there are no product placements in the movie, there's a ton of Brave merchandise available, particularly aimed at girls.


This review of Brave was written by
Age
9
Based on 120 parent & educator reviews:
  • 73% say violence is an issue
  • 39% say there are positive messages
  • 36% say there are positive role models

Most useful reviews by all members

Parent
June 22, 2012
 
HUGE disappointment, and not what it seems :(
Sooo disappointed! If you have seen the previews, then you have essentially seen the first 15 minutes or so of the movie (which I thought looked really cute)... after that it takes a weird twist and the rest of the movie is about witches, spirits, evil bears, etc. My daughter and her 8 year old friends had their eyes covered for a good portion of the movie and ended up sitting on laps because they were too scared. If we weren't there with friends, we would have walked out. Any message about mother-daughter bonding is superficial at best, and almost completely lost in all of the dark, scary parts. On top of that, the character development was poor (and largely non-existent for anyone but the main character), and the storyline was choppy. There were also quite a few naked hineys in the movie, which might bother some parents. We were so excited about this movie that we went to the midnight showing, but we felt like it was not at all what it seemed. We went with a couple other families and they all felt the same, so I don't think it was just us. Even my daughter said she would not want to watch it again (she said she would rather watch Tangled). Some people might rate it as "OK," but I would be surprised to see anyone rate this as a great movie. Personally, I wish I would have just stayed home and gotten a couple more hours of sleep!

Parent
June 22, 2012
 
Brave is Definitely PG!!
My 5 & 7 YO daughters hated our trip to the cinema today! They told me they'd have 'nightmares for seven weeks!' over this movie. Why, oh why do studios market PG movies to little children?! My kids spent more time with their faces buried under the crooks of my arms than they did looking at the screen. I spent more time assuring them that the king wouldn't accidentally kill his wife--the mother of the heroine--before the end of the movie. "I PROMISE, it *will* have a happy ending!" x12. It's a pretty movie. The storyline for "How To Train Your Dragon" was way better. I'm disappointed because Pixar (et al) had a flame-haired opportunity to shine, to really develop that non-traditional heroine character. They did not do that, but they still turned in a decent bit of entertainment.

Parent
June 23, 2012
 
Disney Has Lost Their Mind
Disney has lost their mind. This movie should be PG13, although I do think it's ok for a 9 or 10 year old. But if you are expecting your normal Pixar Disney film, you aren't going to get it here. Why Disney would want to make a violent film that scares children, I have no idea. I expect more from them than cheap scare tactics for shock value. Usually when Disney has violence in their movies, there is humor to break it up. (For example the old man in Up fighting with his walker). Brave has none of that. We've gotten to the point that animation is so real looking that when a bear gets shot up with 20 arrows, you might as well see a real bear getting shot up with 20 arrows. I would put the violence level at the Spiderman movies or Pirates of the Caribbean. The difference is bears are real and kids know that superheroes and pirates aren't. Have fun taking your little one on a nature hike in a National Park after watching this movie. I just wish I would have walked out when I first felt uncomfortable, but I kept trusting Disney that it was only one scene. The fault is my own. If a movie isn't G, you really need to read about it first. Even if it has the Disney and Pixar name. They have no right marketing a movie like this on Disney Junior when it's clearly geared to a 10 year old. Up until now, PG Disney movies like Up, The Incredibles, and Bolt haven't tried to scare children, so I didn't think I had any reason to worry about the PG rating. Boy was I wrong.

Parent
June 22, 2012
 
Too scary for young children!!!
WARNING!!! This movie has some VERY scary scenes. I have taken my kids to the movies since they were 2-3 years old and they are 5 and 7 now. I have NEVER had to leave a movie and they begged me to leave in the middle of it. They were terrified. Very disappointed by Disney with the scary content and unnessisary violence in this movie.

Parent of 6 and 8 year old
June 22, 2012
 
Too scary
We were so excited to see Brave today -- I had heard so much about the positive messages and strong female lead. Well, we were very disappointed. The movie was very intense and dark -- I am really surprised that commonsense.org rated it ON for ages 6 and up. I took my 8 year old and 6 year old, and both kids were terrified. They both sat on my lap for most of the movie, and my 6 year old cried several times and wanted to leave. I probably should have just left, but I did want them to know that everything turned out ok in the end (plus we spent a small fortune to see the evening showing in 3D). It wasn't just us, either -- we went with a group of friends, and many of the kids were crying and/or sitting on moms' laps throughout the movie. Overall, I didn't even think the message was that great, and the storyline was not very interesting at all. I'm glad that Disney tried to make a strong female lead for their newest Pixar film, but Brave fell short, in my opinion.

Parent
June 22, 2012
 
GREAT movie for (mature) 5 & up!!!
This was definitely one of the best Disney Pixar films we've ever seen. The animation was STUNNING, the story was action-packed & funny, and Merida, the star of the show, is by far Disney's most inspiring, real-girl princess yet. My boys are 12 & 9 and my daughter is 5 (almost 6,) and all 3 kids LOVED it. My daughter said "it was kind of scary in some parts, but not too scary." On that note, if you have a child younger than 5 (or a very sensitive 5,) think twice before taking him/her to see this movie, because the vicious bear scenes might be too scary. I'd say the bear scenes were the only reason this is rated PG instead of G (well, maybe the brief glimpse of the Scotsmen's bare bottoms had something to do with it, too,) but I'm VERY selective about what I let my children watch, & I'd have no problem letting them see this one again. Yes, there were lots of weapons used throughout the movie (it's set in Medieval Scotland,) but no overt violence...no blood or gore. I, personally, loved this movie. I love almost all Disney Pixar movies, but this one was especially entertaining. Unlike the reviewer above, I found the portrayal of the mother-daughter relationship to be realistic and, at the end, touching and inspirational. Spend the extra $ for the 3D version at the theater...you won't regret it.

Parent
June 22, 2012
 
"Brave" requires bravery to watch with younger children...
We saw "Brave" this morning on it's release day. The title is appropriate: your children need to be brave to see this film. It was extremely intense at moments, both of my children cried - one wanted to leave during the most intense part. It is overall a good movie and as with all Disney films - ends on a happy note. I enjoyed it even though I found it quite scary at times. We all cried at the end and not just because it was touching - it was quite sad before the final "bow" was put on the story. I included the "sex" portion of the review due to the many close ups of the ample bosom house maid that was featured more times than seemed appropriate. I've accepted that all Disney movies have the "bad guy" or "scary" part - this one just caught me off guard a bit by the intensity. It was good - my younger child bounced back quickly after it was over & said she liked it...my older child will most likely be up tonight with bad dreams.

Parent of 2 and 9 year old
June 22, 2012
 
Breathtaking film, great for all ages!
I've been eagerly waiting for the release of Brave for over a year now, and it was well worth it. Tonight was the midnight premiere and I went with a group of friends (will take the kids during a daytime showing for sure!) Needless to say, we were all in awe at another marriage of Disney/Pixar magic. The story takes place in 10th century Scotland and centres around the life of 16 year old Princess Merida and her family. There is a heavy emphasis on mother-daughter bonding, and how difficult and tedious it can be when the two don't think alike. Her mother Elinor is a typical elegant, strictly trained and proper queen, while Merida is a raucous tomboy with a thirst for adventure and honing her already amazing archery skills. Merida seeks the help of an old witch to change her mother's personality in hopes of avoiding an arranged marriage which her mother is extremely adamant on making her go through, but gets far more (and far worse) than she bargained for. *No spoilers ;) * Brave is a visually stunning film with a rich, endearing, and gripping story that does have some considerably dark undertones. Despite the fact that Merida (a princess) is the main character, this is a far cry from the traditional cutesy Disney princess films; Merida is fiercely independent and asserts herself when faced with an arranged marriage (and even ends up without a love interest in the end) and doesn't let her status and expectations hold her back. There is no graphic violence, while there are scenes of two bears fighting. Since these are viking-like warriors (the men) there are a lot of swords, arrows, axes and maces shown and used, but there is no blood or visual injury being caused to other characters, other than a small scratch Merida gets on her arm while getting in the way of her father's sword and the bear. As for "sexy stuff" this is a Disney/Pixar movie, so obviously, no, there is no sex, but there is some minor nudity (for comic relief purposes) Pixar stayed true to old world clothing; the men are naked beneath their kilts. There is a scene where Lord Dingwall's son wins Merida's hand in marriage, and he "moons" the other Lords to rub it in their faces. There is another scene where the men get trapped on the roof of the castle and have to link their kilts together to make a rope for escape; as they're walking away you see a few shots of their rear ends--same in a scene with Merida's younger brothers at the end of the movie. Lastly, there are a few between Fergus and Elinor. They're a happily married couple, in the beginning, Fergus gives Elinor a little smack on the rear, and at the end, she is naked beneath a tapestry (nothing below her neck and shoulders is visible). So nothing that problematic, still very comical and kid-friendly. In the end, the movie has some great lessons and role models kids can learn from, and speaking as an adult who just saw the movie, I can completely say that it is enjoyable for all ages. Highly recommended, wonderful movie! On for ages 5 and up.

Parent
June 22, 2012
 
Great message - but scary for little ones
As an adult and parent, I thoroughly enjoyed the excitement and strong spirit of young Merida. I thought it would be a bit pedestrian, judging from the trailers, so I was not prepared for the some of the scenes we watched with 5 young children (age 4-9). The creepy witch in the forest, and very violent bear scenes were upsetting - for some the children - and we covered their eyes. Not crying, 'I want to leave the theater' kind of scary, but I worried about nightmares or lingering fears about losing a parent. It never occurred to me that I would have to be wary - the trailers were tame, it was an animated rated G (I thought) film, and I don't associate Pixar with scary films. I wish there was a more noticeable warning for parents, so I would plan it differently (ie, not take the littlest ones, warn the ones I think could be frightened, or schedule some fun lighthearted activity immediately after). Having said all that, I still think it is a great film with a superb message for both girl-princess-wanna-be's and boys comfortable with strong female role models. The first half was hysterically funny (every parent can relate to chasing wild-eyed mischievous boys), and the message was strong and positive. I enjoyed it thoroughly but would not recommend it for children under 8....since I watched the end with 3 youngsters on my lap.

Parent of 7 and 14 year old
June 22, 2012
 
Very Good Movie
Very, very good - could have been a little less scary and had a little more detail about Scotland and its history and why there are no bears there anymore. Too scary for 6-year olds.

(PG, 2007)

Adorable fairy tale is a fabulous family flick.

(G, 1991)

The ultimate makeover story has strong, positive messages.

(PG, 2010)

Fantastic princess adventure is fun, with great messages.

(G, 2009)

First African-American Disney princess is a good role model.