Review

Sid Meier's Civilization V

Common Sense Media says

Excellent strategy game is educational and accessible.
Age
11
Quality
 
Learning
4

  • This game explores how civilizations come into existence, thrive, and war with one another. It encourages players to experiment with various governments, policies, and ideologies to learn about their advantages and disadvantages as they guide societies toward military, cultural, diplomatic, scientific, or economic victory.
  • The game features a mix of 18 famous and infamous historical leaders, including George Washington, Queen Elizabeth, Napoleon, and Augustus Caesar. While each leader comes with his or her own tactical bonuses that may lend themselves to a particular way of playing, ruling style is determined solely by the player.
  • Far and away the most accessible PC-based Civilization game to date, players’ hands are held through every step, with important information automatically popping up on screen and all available actions each turn shown in the bottom right corner. It can still be devilishly difficult on hard settings, but players should experience no trouble learning how to play.
  • A wide variety of historical military units -- swordsmen, musketeers, tanks, and bombers -- fight each other from a bird’s-eye view. Faint cries of pain can be heard, and soldiers crumple and disappear when defeated. Nuclear explosions can wipe out entire cities. There is no blood or gore.

What parents need to know

Parents need to know that Sid Meier’s Civilization V uses authentic historical elements -- famous leaders, nations, resources, military units -- to simulate non-historical empires. In other words, players can, say, lead Gandhi’s India through millennia of military rule or have Napolean’s France become an empire of diplomacy and science. Though the simulated history is fictional, players can still learn a great deal, not just about real-world figures, concepts, and units, but also how cultural, ideological, and geographical factors can change a world’s geopolitical landscape. Play necessitates the depiction of some violence, but it is presented from a high perspective and is quite mild. While it is the most accessible PC-based Civilization game to date, it is still a deep, complex, and demanding game that could prove frustrating for younger players. Keep in mind, too, that online play supports open text and voice chat. Common Sense Media does not recommend moderation-free online communication for pre-teens.


This review of Sid Meier's Civilization V was written by
Age
9
Based on 3 parent & educator reviews:
  • 33% say violence is an issue
  • 33% say there are positive messages
  • 33% say it's educational

Most useful reviews by all members

Kid, 12 years old
November 14, 2010
 
Awesome, but you'll need a good computer!
Civ 5 is finally here! I played it for a minute and was instantly pulled in! However, being new, it needs a good computer! I would suggest Quad Core Processor on a desktop. Still, great game all around! Great for anyone who truly appreciates a good strategy game!

Kid, 12 years old
October 28, 2010
 
GREAT
This is probably the best computer game-ever. It's fun, and it can be as easy, or as hard, as you want it to be. You can also make your own map (you have to download a pack but I think it's free) and you can play with other people. And if you go into the Civilapedia you can learn the history of practically everything that's in the game. Great, just... five stars. (and it has amazing graphics)

Kid, 10 years old
October 16, 2010
 
nice game but you need to undrstand what you are resurching
this game is a sequal to a great seires. in this game you get to be a great figure in history and take on history your way. if you are a fan of Civilization IV, you may be disapointed that when you choose a map, the map does not randomise itself so you may find yourself playing on the same contenent for 6 games straght. some of t6he things that you can reserch unget kids might not understand, like anamal husbandry. great game A+

Teen, 16 years old
July 15, 2011
 
A word of caution
Civilization 5 requires internet access to install, so if you have an unstable or nonexistant internet connection, don't bother getting it. I was so disappointed(my age review is from Civ 4).

Teen, 13 years old
December 25, 2011
 
fun
Its really fine for all ages, but kids younger than 9 probably wont understand.

Parent of 8, 14, and 17 year old
June 22, 2012
 
Learning2
My 8 yr old son and I have a blast multiplayer.
My kids really enjoy playing Civilization V and we also play multiplayer together.

Teen, 14 years old
December 24, 2011
 
A great game though HARD ease of play!
A great game for almost anyone. The game itself is very complicated and it can take a very boring, long time to understand if u didnt play any of the others. Still, a very good game.

Adult
April 19, 2012
 
Civilization V - incredibly fun, and highly educational
Civilization V is a stunningly enjoyable game which has the potential to inspire people of all ages to learn more about history. Although it does not present an accurate portrayal of historical events (as it allows each player to choose their own path), it presents the course of human history and civilization as a fascinating journey. Even more importantly, the emphasis it places on long-term strategic thinking and planning promotes strong development of decision-making and reasoning skills. Although the game does not present a specific sense of morality, this ambiguity allows players to think intelligently about the choices they make and the real impact those choices will have on their virtual subjects. This might be lost on younger players, but it's a great idea to talk about this with older, thoughtful children. In many senses, this game is a lot like chess for the twenty-first century. People play it as entertainment, not to learn, but while playing Civilization V, learning is almost unavoidable, even if you don't notice because you're having too much fun. Although I rated the game as being appropriate for anybody over the age of 8, that's a reference to the content, not the difficulty. Even on the easiest setting, the game will most likely be too difficult for most children under the age of twelve or so, unless an older player helps them as they learn the game. The game can be violent in a sense, but roughly in the same sense that chess is violent: in chess, you move pieces from one tile to another on the game board, taking over the territory that your opponent's pieces once occupied. Although the combat in Civilization V is dressed up with fancier graphics and some sound effects, it's relatively abstract like chess, as though you're moving a token on a game board. In summation, Civilization V is loads of fun, and also a genuinely positive experience, challenging players to engage in creative planning, weighing priorities, calculating risks, adapting to changing scenarios, and considering the morality of their actions. I have been playing the Civilization series of computer games since I was a child, and it took me decades to realize just how much I was learning from it. The beauty is, you don't learn facts - you learn how to *think*, and that's the most important type of learning there is.

Kid, 9 years old
June 15, 2012
 
Learning3
Educational
No sex, but the safe issue. It is a Steam game, so it may be unsafe for little kids. Plus, it has stabbing aiming, and shooting.

Kid, 12 years old
November 28, 2012
 
Learning3
Smart history game
it's a fun game, but it has some violence in big figts. The figts do not include blod. You and the child can get smarter in history!

(Nintendo DS, Nintendo DSi)

Puzzles meet strategy in fun fantasy for older kids.

(Windows)
A brainy twist on the Civilization formula.
(Xbox 360, PlayStation 3, Windows)

Deep war game requires brain as well as (moderate) brawn.