Review

The Fellowship of the Ring

Common Sense Media says

Spectacular fantasy classic is where Frodo's journey begins.
Age
12
Quality
 

  • This is one of the best contemporary examples of what scholar Joseph Campbell calls the Monomyth or Hero's Journey (another is the Star Wars series). Tolkien is also greatly admired for his "world building": he paints an unbelievably complete picture of Middle Earth with maps, dense background history of each race (elves, dwarves, different kingdoms of humans, hobbits), poems and songs, and even whole languages and scripts to pen them in.
  • Good vs. evil is at the heart of this trilogy and the stakes are very high. Many races must come together to fight and the smallest and most innocent carry the heaviest burden. Gandalf teaches a lesson in mercy to Frodo when he spares Gollum after his suffering. And the character Tom Bombadil teaches a profound eco-lesson, believing that "the trees and the grasses and all things growing or living in the land belong each to themselves."
  • Frodo is the unlikely and, at first, reluctant hero who begins to accept his grave responsibility at great personal sacrifice. Sam is incredibly loyal to Frodo and rather untrusting of others. Both Gandolf and Strider are good protectors of the company. Boramir battles with himself to keep the ring from ensnaring him.
  • Frodo and his hobbit friends are pursued by sinister riders in black, undead and cursed servants of the enemy, for their journey alone. They are also stripped and held captive by Barrow-wights in caves. Frodo is stabbed and nearly dies. The Fellowship faces danger in a snowstorm, from hungry wolves, and then in the creepy, dark mining caves of Moria pursued by orcs and trolls and then a demon; they lose one in their company and mourn. They fight with swords, bows, and some magic. An inner battle is waged at the same time, debilitating anyone who has been a ring-bearer; a story is told of Gollum first strangling a friend who found the ring.
  • Not applicable.
  • One use of "ass."
  • Not applicable.
  • Pipe-weed is smoked often by hobbits, Gandalf, and Strider (the Prologue includes an explanation of how hobbits and then other races came to grow and consume it). Wine and beer are consumed at social gatherings and thought about longingly while traveling.

What parents need to know

Parents need to know that if kids are ready to see the excellent Lord of the Rings movies they're ready to read the trilogy, starting with The Fellowship of the Ring -- though arguably scenes fighting orcs and worse in the mines of Moria and ones with the undead dark riders pursuing the hobbits can seem extra creepy when you take the book to bed. One character almost dies and one is mourned; there's some fighting with swords and bows, but giant battle scenes are saved for the next two books. The hobbits and men like to smoke their pipe-weed and drink wine and beer. They also sing long ballads, sometimes in the author's made-up languages -- Tolkien's Middle Earth is just that fully imagined.


This review of The Fellowship of the Ring was written by
Age
7

Most useful reviews by all members

Parent of 5, 9, 11, and 14 year old
January 4, 2009
 

Adult
April 9, 2008
 

Teen, 14 years old
August 19, 2009
 
An Absolutely Fabulous book to be enjoyed and marveled at by older tweens and up!
The reason I rated this iffy for 12 year olds is not due to content but simply because I am unsure whether kids under 12, and in fact even some 12 year olds, will be able to get through this book. If they can, then by all means let them read it, as this is an enchanting and beautiful masterpiece. The world that Tolkien has created feels just as real as the world we live in. Descriptions wonderfully detailed and in depth, story and story telling absolutely fantastic, and marvelously wonderful and likeable characters fill this book. A must read for anyone who can read a book this deap and thoughtful, especially fantasy lovers.

Teen, 13 years old
April 9, 2008
 
this is the best book on the planet!!!!
I loved this book Tolkien is a genius! The plot line is great and the charcters seem real. If you haven't read this book you need to.

Teen, 17 years old
April 9, 2008
 
one of the best written
a great read!!! middle-earth and everyone there are all vividly described so well that you feel your there! when i first got it, i wouldnt read anything else for a couple months, i just kept re-reading the series! its a wonderful masterpiece, its such a good book that i cannot say enough words of praise! the lord of the rings to me is the best fanatasy ever written! it has good morals, no swearing, no sex, and though there is violence you may note that its not described in detail. everything we want in our own lives, and in the world, exists in middle-earth. you will never want to leave!

Teen, 14 years old
April 9, 2008
 
A must read book!
This is an amazing book. Everyone should read it! This is not a book for little kids. It is too in depth and scary for younger kids. They wouldn't get it. It is a very exciting and wonderful story for teens and adults.

Adult
April 9, 2008
 
A Good Read
Out of the trilogy, I finished this one the quickest. I love Tolkien's style of writing and the words he uses for description. I found in reading this, quite a few good quotes and the like. One of the best parts of this books are the songs or poems told in. Not a lot of authors do that...

Kid, 9 years old
April 9, 2008
 
This book is unbelievable.
In this book, you go to the shire, Anduin, Rivendell, Moria, and more. But if you thought this was good, just read the other two books in the trilogy. Also, at the end, the loss of Boromir is tragic, but it can show what happens - sometimes - when consumed by greed. Two thumbs up though.

Teen, 13 years old
January 16, 2009
 
Amazing Classic
The Fellowship of the Ring might not be so action-packed at the start like recent fantasy stories these days, and contain archaic (if i might use that term) english terms that made me a little more than confused at first--but the description and creations are AMAZING. A must read. Best fantasy book of all time.

Teen, 15 years old
April 9, 2008
 
Not so grate. Gets boring at times, but OK.

(by Homer)

Essential, epic poem of Greek gods, monsters, and heroes.

(PG, 1980)

The best of the original series, but the most intense, too.

(by J.R.R. Tolkien)

Brilliantly written, inventive pre-LOTR tale.

(by Rick Riordan)

Modernized Greek myths meet fast-paced adventure.