Review

Roll of Thunder, Hear My Cry

Common Sense Media says

A family deals with racism in a Mississippi town.
Age
11
Quality
 

  • Not applicable.
  • Racial slurs; the book portrays -- but does not condone -- a racist society.
  • Children disobey their teacher, sabotage a school bus out of revenge,
    fight, and cheat on an exam; characters break into a store and steal.
  • Three men are set on fire; children are whipped by teacher and parents; children fight with each other; a teenage boy is beaten by some older men; one man is shot. People are killed; the family is threatened by a white neighbor and by fire; a mob threatens people; and there are vague references to rape.

What parents need to know

Parents need to know that with lyrical, compelling prose, the story builds to a fiery climax, but it's sometimes sidetracked by long sections of background information.


This review of Roll of Thunder, Hear My Cry was written by
Age
11
Based on 19 parent & educator reviews:
  • 26% say there are positive role models
  • 26% say there are positive messages
  • 26% say language is an issue

Most useful reviews by all members

Teen, 13 years old
November 20, 2011
 
good or bad what do u think!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I am in 6th grade and i just read the book in literacy class it was one of the best books. I've read even when it said the N WORD it was only to make a point about how mean people were back then and the people that dont like the book because of that WORD they should't because its total wrong to do that !!!!!! i recommomed that chlidren everwhere should read this book in 5 or 6th grade if they dont like it , its ok but i dont want it to be because of one word use alot in the book

Teen, 13 years old
April 9, 2008
 
very important but sometimes boring
i think this is a really important book for kids to read, especially if they are racist. it would really make a difference to their attitude if they started looking at the people they scorn (or worse) as just that- people. however, it might have been more effective if the author didn't bog you down with lots of background history and information that doesn't directly apply to the story- it kind of turned me off.

Parent
July 15, 2011
 
greaty
it is a good book because it teaches kids how far we have came.

Parent of 8 and 11 year old
August 16, 2010
 
I love this book. I loved it when I was in the target audience, I loved using it as a read-aloud with middle schoolers in Georgia as part of our advising time, and I loved listening to it on audiobook in the car with my children last week. There is plenty to learn about the time, but there are also ongoing themes about children choosing their friends, how to be a good friend and an honorable person, how individuals can empower themselves and each other in an unjust world. Over and over we understand that one does not have to act a certain way, just because one is part of a certain group. We also come to understand that even those who seem to be in opposition to us may also have redeeming features; that we may work together on the things we *do* have in common. Contrary to Jesusrulz666, I found that the messages throughout were about individuals making daily choices about themselves, their friends, their actions, and about how those choices affect both the people around them and their communities one step removed; not about government knowing best at all. My younger daughter is just 8, so hearing this book all at once (in 2 7-hour car rides) with everyone together for stop-and-explain times, worked for her. She would not have been ready to read it on her own, and she's already had some exposure to Jim Crow and desegregation (notably Ruby Bridges book and movie). My older daughter (11) had already read it before we listened.

Teen, 13 years old
February 10, 2011
 
I have to read this book for English, and it is great so far. As an African American student I can be grateful that I didn't live back then. There are some iffy racist words like N*****r and things but it's a good historical fiction book.

Teen, 13 years old
February 11, 2011
 
i love the book but it kind of raciest because the white kid slapsh the cassise and lilman and tj and chisterjhon. then all of them prank the whites and dig an hole for when their bus went by the bus got suck lol,and at the began it says n**** then in chapter 3 its says n**** n*******! am black !

Teen, 13 years old
April 28, 2011
 
This is a great book that is set in the 1930s. Mildred Taylor is a great author who is not afraid to tell about what happen to many Afriacan Americans before, and durring the time set within the book. Altough Taylor has used some strong language in the book such as negro and n****r. Roll of Tunder Hear My Cry has a positive message but somewhat lacks in having supportive roll models. There is some violence in the book such as burnings, whippings, instants that involve the K.K.K., and disrespect between white and black like it was back in the 1900s.

Teen, 14 years old
November 15, 2010
 
oh....I love this book it is one of my favorite

Teen, 13 years old
October 9, 2010
 
I loved it. The book is educational as it is based on life in mississippi in the 1940's and the charectors in the book are good role models as they stand up for what they believe is right , they have self respect for them selves and show it to others that deserve it to. It may have racist comments in them but there are people from both of the race's communities that disagree with it. The book shows that racism is wrong and they you should'nt accept it . Mildred Taylor has portrayed many charcters in this book using them to show about the morals and the ways of living in ' the old south ' .

Kid, 11 years old
January 7, 2011
 
A Great Book!
Just yesterday, we were assigned this book for literature studies. The first chapter is so good. It basically brings you right to the scene of the book. So far, there aren't any main concerns, however it is dealt with racism, basically blacks against whites. Which to me I think that younger kids wouldn't quite have the knowledge yet to understand.

(by Christopher Paul Curtis)

Humorous, powerful, masterful escaped-slave tale.

(by Harper Lee)

Stunning classic examines racism -- and justice.

(by Jane Yolen)
Intense Holocaust story makes history real.