Review

Anne Frank: The Diary of a Young Girl

Common Sense Media says

Inspiring wartime journal reveals teen's inner life.
Age
11
Quality
 

  • Anne Frank's beautifully written diary is a teaching tool on multiple levels. First, it offers a kid's eye view of World War II, written innocently and meaningfully by a Jewish teen whose family is forced into hiding during the Nazi occupation of Holland. Anne follows the events of the war via radio news broadcasts and information shared by visiting friends, as she and her family anxiously await the allies' invasion of continental Europe. Second, the book is enormously telling about the inner life of girls in their early teens. Anne articulately describes her own emotional and physical feelings as she matures, including her struggles to get along with her parents, the beginnings of her sexuality and desire for love, and her wish to make a difference in a troubled world. On another level, Anne also devotes her time to studying history, literature, mathematics, and languages (though she admits she doesn't care for algebra). Her family places a high value on education, and her father becomes her teacher as well while they are in hiding. Anne writes to relieve her stress, share with a "friend," and unburden her feelings, repeatedly referring to a quote: "Paper is more patient than man."
  • Despite their fear, hunger, and harsh living conditions, the Franks and their fellow inmates of the "secret annex" show amazing courage and commitment to family. Anne writes movingly about the unjust treatment of Jews, and her goal of helping make the world a better place after the war. Equally inspiring is the relationship between the families in the secret annex and the friends outside who protect and feed them. The Franks also continue to observe their faith and other family rituals while in hiding. Most remarkable is just how normal Anne is, in spite of everything, which in itself offers a reassuring message of resilience for teens and parents of teens.
  • Anne Frank dreamed of becoming a great writer, and she achieved that goal, though she didn't live to see her words published. In the book, she shines through as a very normal teen with talent, spirit, and a hunger for learning. Adults in Anne's diary argue and struggle with each other -- we can only imagine their stress and anxiety -- and Anne is often at odds with the grownups, but all of these people, and their friends on the outside, inspire great admiration for keeping two families alive under extreme duress for two years. The adult Anne most appreciates is her father, who seems quiet, kind, and intelligent.
  • Anne and her family can hear air raids and shooting. They also regularly receive news of the war, and of friends and acquaintances being taken away to concentration camps, though it is not clear how much they know about what happens in the camps. The threat of violence is always present; the warehouse that contains the secret annex is invaded by burglars several times, bringing not only immediate danger, but the fear that the families will be seen and reported to the German police.
  • Anne writes about her growing sexual feelings; she says that sometimes she wants nothing but time alone to feel her breasts and listen to the beating of her own heart. She also mentions having once kissed a girlfriend and having asked that friend if they should feel each other's breasts, but the friend refused. Anne also writes a lot about her feelings of "longing" for Peter Van Daan, a teen boy whose family shares the secret annex with the Franks. She and Peter embrace and share their first kisses.
  • Not applicable.
  • Not applicable.
  • Mr. Van Daan smokes cigarettes, and the Franks' friends on the outside talk about drinking wine at parties.

What parents need to know

Parents need to know that Anne Frank's diary is a singular, moving look at World War II from a young girl's perspective. The Franks, along with another family, the Van Daans, hide in order to avoid capture during the German occupation of Holland. Aided by friends on the outside, Anne and the others spend two years in the "secret annex": several rooms enclosed in the warehouse of Anne's father's business. While war rages outside, Anne is a normal teen, thinking at least as much about friends, and boyfriends, and how her parents annoy her, as she does about issues of the day. She is a remarkably clever, thoughtful narrator, and her diary is as entertaining as it is a significant historical document.

Anne Frank: The Diary of a Young Girl is required reading for many middle-schoolers, and it will be rightfully upsetting to many of those readers. Though the events within the diary offer only a glimpse of the horrors inflicted on Jewish people by the Nazis, there is a disturbing element of fear throughout. What we as readers know about what happened to Jews outside the world of the book, and what happened to Anne after the book ends, is inescapable in the experience of reading Anne's diary.

Many editions of Anne Frank's diary include an Afterword, explaining the events of World War II and the fate of Anne and the other inmates of the secret annex.


This review of Anne Frank: The Diary of a Young Girl was written by
Age
11
Based on 3 parent & educator reviews:
  • 100% say it's educational
  • 100% say there are positive messages
  • 67% say sexual content is an issue
  • 67% say there are positive role models
  • 33% say violence is an issue

Most useful reviews by all members

Teen, 13 years old
November 3, 2011
 
AWESOME
I read this book when I was about 8 and then again when I was 14. I think that it is good 8 and up.

Teen, 13 years old
October 9, 2011
 
Positive Role Models and Messages
I really loved this! I read it in sixth grade and it has really good role models and messages.

Kid, 11 years old
February 19, 2012
 
Detailed, Precise, To-The-Point Review For Worried Parents Who Want The Best For Their Child
There are 2 editions of Anne Frank's diary. Since I read The Definitive Edition (which I say is for GIRLS 12+) I am here to review that. I suggest males to read the critical edition as it has much less content. I will tell you any iffy and suggestive things that ticked me off, but I, not knowing who you nor who your child is, cannot tell you to let your child read or not. I list the pros and cons, you decide "yay" or "nay." Here goes: **There is no language, no consumerism (duh, it takes place in the 40's!)So don't worry about THAT. **Anne talks about menstruation and how she anxiously awaits her period. Sometimes, she says she needs sanitary pads or tampons, but those are scarce because of the fact that they're made of cotton/plastic for the war. She also says her and Margot's bras no longer fit. She wants to go shopping for bras, but as she is in hiding, she can't. **She talks about feeling a deep desire to touch her breasts and how she used to be very curious about her friend, Jacque, and her body. She asked Jacque if they could touch each other's breasts for proof of their friendship. Jacque refused, but later on, Anne kisses her, whether that's on her cheek or lips, she does not say. **Anne talks about sex and says that she and Peter, her boyfriend (who, by the way, neither Anne's nor Peter's parents know they're secretly in a relationship) often speak of that topic. On one certain page of the diary, Peter describes the private part of a male and Anne spends quite a long time describing that of a female. ***Lots of Violence: Anne speaks of air raids, bombs, etc. Often, burglaries occur in Otto's warehouse. And, after all, it IS a book about the Holocaust and the World War II. I think that I covered most of the iffy topics in Anne Frank's Definitive Edition Diary. Thank you for reading, I hope I aided you in your decision of whether or not to allow your child to read "Anne Frank: The Diary of a Young Girl: The Definitive Edition."

Parent of 5 and 8 year old
November 27, 2011
 
Overall, something everyone should read
This was a excellent book for learning for my daughter who is 8 years. I read it with her which I would recomend doing if your kid wants to read the book but does gets scared or disturbed by books.

Parent
December 24, 2011
 
The best book ever!
I first read Anne's diary when I was in 6th grade, and as I read it, I got more interested in the entire book. Over the past few years, I kept on reading the book almost every month. I highly recommend Anne's diary!

Kid, 11 years old
May 19, 2012
 
ANNE FRANK, (by Neve372000)
"The Diary of Anne Frank" is very very sad. Anne is a jew, so she is forced to hide from Hitler. I won't tell you how it ends, but i will tell you to buy lots of tissues.

Teen, 14 years old
March 13, 2012
 
good

Teen, 13 years old
April 23, 2012
 
Amazing
this is a great way for younger people to learn about the Holocaust and what really happened

Teen, 13 years old
May 17, 2012
 
I love Anne frank the book
We are reading this book in class as a class novel. Not once have I ever been so interested in a book my whole life. The whole class is begging to read more pages because we only read it once a day :( My knowledge on world war II has grown so much considering I only knew so little. I feel as if I know Anne and when she's writing diary entries to 'kitty' I feel as though there to me. Words can't describe how strongly I recommend this awesome book! YOU HAVE TO READ IT! :) :) :) :)

Parent
May 31, 2012
 
Depends on what edition you read.
Definitive edition: 12+ Anne describes her relationship with Peter, how she kissed a girl once, and her "parts" Critical edition: 10+ Things have been taken out, not as bad as the definitive edition I read the definitive edition in 6th grade, and I don't have a problem with it.

(PG-13, 2011)

Powerful drama includes horrifying Holocaust violence.

(by Tanita Davis)
Unique African-American woman's WWII experience.
(PG, 1987)

Poignant subtitled WWII story about kids and loss.

(NR, 1963)
An exceptional story about teamwork.